Two Gwent Police constables are facing gross misconduct proceedings over allegations they failed to search the homes of three missing young women — Eve Smith, Darcy Ross and Sophie Russon — before a crash near St Mellons that killed three people and left two seriously injured. Police Constable 2407 Richard Hardwick and Police Constable 2392 Lauren Livingstone deny all allegations of breaching the Standards of Professional Behaviour in respect of honesty and integrity, and duties and responsibilities. The hearing, chaired by Ian Arundale, opened on Monday, 16 November 2026.
Daily Dazzling Dawn understands the proceedings arise from an Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) investigation into the handling of missing persons reports filed on Saturday, 4 March 2023. Eve Smith and Darcy Ross, both 21 and from Newport, and Rafel Jeanne, 24, from Cardiff, were pronounced dead at the scene after the Volkswagen Tiguan they were travelling in left the A48 near St Mellons. The vehicle was discovered on Monday, 6 March 2023 — almost 48 hours after the group was last seen. Passengers Sophie Russon, then 20, and Shane Loughlin, then 32, were found seriously injured and survived.
Daily Dazzling Dawn learned that families of Miss Smith and Miss Russon reported them missing at approximately 7.30pm on 4 March 2023. The allegations before the panel state that the home addresses were not searched as required by missing persons' conduct. The hearing was told that a full log was created for Darcy Ross and Sophie Russon after they had not been in contact since around 10.30pm that night, but that it was wrongly understood at the time that a close family relative had to be the person reporting someone missing — so a full log was not initially made for Eve Smith. Her mother, Emma Borg, later found her daughter's handbag at a caravan on Treco Bay and called 101, with full logs for Eve Smith created at that point.
It has been put to both officers that their entries on the logs for each missing person were consistent with allegations of dishonesty. The panel heard that the required paperwork asked officers to confirm whether a premises search had been conducted. Both officers reportedly indicated that searches had taken place, when it is alleged no such searches were made. The hearing was told these claims amounted to a "very serious failing" at the outset of a missing persons' investigation and allegedly misled investigating officers.
PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone were tasked with searching the homes of those reported missing. The hearing heard they attended Sophie Russon's home at around 11.30pm on the Saturday and spoke to her father. In his statement to the IOPC, Mr Russon said the officers did not search the home or Sophie's bedroom but did ask him questions, and that he would have refused a request to search the house had one been made. He is due to give evidence on Tuesday.
The officers then went to Eve Smith's home at around 11.50pm. Eve's brother, who was at home when they arrived, said in his statement that the officers did not search the house and did not ask to do so. Eve's mother, Emma Borg, returned home during the visit and was questioned by the officers; she later confirmed no search took place. Both are due to give evidence. The panel also heard that other officers did search Darcy Ross's home, including entering her bedroom.
Daily Dazzling Dawn understands that when a person is reported missing, a full search of the home address should be carried out as a priority — checking for items left behind that might provide clues to their whereabouts. The panel heard the supervising sergeant needed to know whether the homes had been searched and was told all three had been, as per the attending officers' reports, with the logs updated accordingly.
The families became immediately concerned after a lack of contact by social media or phone, described as "highly unusual", on the evening of 4 March 2023. Mr Russon was not initially worried because Sophie had told him she was staying with the others, but raised the alarm once it became clear multiple women were missing. The vehicle was eventually found having left the road near the roundabout on the A48 near St Mellons in the early hours of 6 March, though it is believed to have left the road in the early hours of Saturday, 4 March.
The hearing continues, with evidence expected from Eve Smith's mother and brother, followed by further evidence from Miss Russon's family on Tuesday. The prosecution is expected to complete its evidence by lunchtime that day. If proven, the allegations of gross misconduct would justify the dismissal of both officers from Gwent Police without notice. Both officers deny all allegations regarding the conduct of the missing persons reports.