.svg)
Jeremy Corbyn and Zarah Sultana are both prominent figures on the left wing of the Labour Party in the UK, but they are not the same person, and their relationship is not one of a single cause-and-effect "failing." Zarah Sultana is a Member of Parliament for Coventry South, known for her socialist views and activism. Jeremy Corbyn is the former leader of the Labour Party and has been a long-serving MP for Islington North.
They are often seen as allies, and both have faced criticism from the more moderate elements of the Labour Party. The provided text from Yanis Varoufakis and Ken Loach, which mentions a "public row," does not explicitly state that this row is between Corbyn and Sultana. It is more likely a reference to internal disagreements within a broader left-wing movement or a potential new party, possibly the "Your Party" mentioned in the text.
Is Zarah Sultana responsible for Jeremy Corbyn's political "failing"?
No, it is inaccurate to attribute Jeremy Corbyn's political struggles or the broader challenges of the British left solely to Zarah Sultana. Corbyn's political career and the issues faced by the left are far more complex. His tenure as Labour leader from 2015 to 2020 was marked by significant internal and external challenges, including:
Brexit: The party's stance on Brexit was seen as ambiguous by many voters, and this contributed to the Labour Party's significant loss in the 2019 general election.
Antisemitism allegations: The Labour Party faced an inquiry by the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) over allegations of antisemitism during Corbyn's leadership. The EHRC found that the party was responsible for unlawful acts of harassment and discrimination.
Media hostility: Corbyn's leadership faced what many of his supporters saw as a consistently hostile media landscape.
Internal opposition: He faced significant opposition from within his own party, with many Labour MPs openly critical of his leadership.
Zarah Sultana was elected as an MP in the 2019 general election and has been a vocal supporter of many of the same causes as Corbyn. However, her political career began at the end of Corbyn's leadership, and she has not held a senior leadership role that would make her the cause of his political "failing."
What are the challenges for a new left-wing party in the UK?
The provided text from Yanis Varoufakis and Ken Loach suggests a desire for a new left-wing party to emerge in the UK, but also highlights the significant challenges it faces. The "public row" and "dispute" mentioned in the text are common issues in the formation of new political movements. They often struggle with:
Internal divisions: Disagreements over strategy, leadership, and policy can quickly derail a new party.
Lack of resources: New parties often lack the financial resources and organizational structure of established parties like Labour or the Conservatives.
Voter recognition: It is difficult to build name recognition and trust with voters, particularly in a first-past-the-post electoral system where voters are often reluctant to "waste" their vote on a smaller party.
Media coverage: Getting fair and consistent media coverage can be a major hurdle.
As of late 2024, Jeremy Corbyn has been an independent MP since being suspended from the Labour Party in 2020. He has stated that he will not stand as a Labour candidate in the next general election but will run as an independent in his Islington North constituency. Zarah Sultana remains the Labour MP for Coventry South.
There has been ongoing discussion and some smaller-scale efforts to create a new political entity on the left, but no single, major party has emerged as a serious challenger to the Labour Party's dominance on the center-left. This aligns with the concerns raised in the Varoufakis and Loach article about the "historic opportunity" being lost due to internal disputes.
